Carragher Urges Amorim’s Immediate Man United Exit Over ‘Disastrous Tenure,’ Cites Key Survival Factor

Pressure Mounts on Ruben Amorim as Manchester United’s Struggles Deepen

Jamie Carragher has called for under-fire Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim to leave the club immediately, labeling his tenure a “disaster” after another dismal performance in their 3-1 defeat to Brentford. The Liverpool legend argued on Monday Night Football that Amorim’s system is incompatible with United’s traditions, and his continued presence harms both the team and his own reputation.

Since taking over in 2023, Amorim has overseen a rapid decline, with United finishing 15th last season and languishing in 14th this term. The loss to Brentford marked a new low, leaving critics questioning the club’s decision-making. Carragher suggested United’s hierarchy, including Sir Jim Ratcliffe, Omar Berrada, and Jason Wilcox, are reluctant to admit another mistake after a string of poor managerial appointments. “They knew Amorim’s rigid tactics from his Sporting Lisbon days,” he said. “Yet they hired him anyway, despite his system clashing with United’s identity.”

Carragher (right) called Amorim’s time at United a “disaster.”

Amorim’s three-at-the-back setup has faced widespread criticism. Everton icon Duncan Ferguson joined the chorus, stating, “The squad is better than this. He hasn’t adapted his tactics despite terrible results.” Carragher added that Amorim’s frequent defensive changes—42 different back-three combinations in 49 games—highlight his stubbornness. “Every other Premier League manager could do better with this squad,” he asserted.

Despite a summer spending spree on players like Benjamin Šeško and Bryan Mbeumo, United’s signings have failed to thrive under Amorim. Carragher noted, however, that the club’s reluctance to fully commit to his system—avoiding excessive spending on center-backs or wing-backs—might ease a transition to a back four under a new manager.

United’s defeat to Brentford added to Amorim’s woes.

Gary Neville echoed concerns, criticizing Amorim’s baffling decisions, such as deploying Mason Mount at left wing-back. “It’s ridiculous. Players look lost in this system,” he said on his podcast. Neville highlighted Mount’s repeated positional struggles as symbolic of Amorim’s flawed tactics.

With pressure escalating, United face a critical stretch: a clash against Sunderland precedes a daunting trip to Liverpool. Many believe Amorim’s fate is sealed, and Carragher urged a swift resolution: “The quicker they part ways, the better for everyone.”

Amorim watches helplessly as United falter again.

As frustration grows among fans and pundits alike, the spotlight turns to United’s leadership. Will they persist with Amorim, or cut ties to salvage their season? For now, the manager’s future hangs by a thread.