Renowned AFL Analyst Stirs Debate with Explosive Critique of Controversial Icon Wayne Carey

Legendary AFL Journalist Backs Wayne Carey for Hall of Fame Legend Status Despite Controversies
By Ed Carruthers for Daily Mail Australia
Published: 23:44 GMT, 20 March 2025 | Updated: 23:47 GMT, 20 March 2025

[IMAGE: Wayne Carey in his North Melbourne glory days, lifting the 1999 premiership cup]
Caption: Carey led North Melbourne to two premierships and remains one of the AFL’s most dominant players.

Veteran journalist Michael Sheahan has sparked debate by urging the AFL to grant troubled North Melbourne icon Wayne Carey “Legend” status in the Australian Football Hall of Fame. Carey, already inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2010, faces resistance due to a string of off-field scandals spanning decades—but Sheahan argues his on-field brilliance outweighs personal failings.

A Complicated Legacy
Carey, 53, is widely regarded as one of the greatest centre-half forwards in AFL history. His accolades include two premierships with North Melbourne (1996, 1999), four club best-and-fairest awards, seven All-Australian selections, and four All-Australian captaincies. Nicknamed “The King,” he revolutionized the role of a key forward with his aerial prowess and leadership.

Yet his legacy remains clouded by controversy. In 2002, Carey’s affair with teammate Anthony Stevens’ wife led to his abrupt exit from North Melbourne. He later admitted the scandal “haunted me for over 20 years.” Legal issues followed, including a 2007 arrest in the U.S. for allegedly assaulting his then-fiancée and altercations with police. In 2022, he was banned from a Perth casino after a bag of white powder reportedly fell from his pocket.

[IMAGE: Carey and Anthony Stevens during their playing days at North Melbourne]
Caption: Carey’s affair with Stevens’ wife fractured their friendship and team dynamics.

Sheahan’s Defense
Sheahan, a revered football writer, insists Carey’s playing career merits recognition. “Short answer, yes,” he told 3AW when asked if Carey deserves Legend status. “Many Legends have skeletons… Where do you draw the line?” He criticized the AFL’s 2023 move to block Carey’s induction into the NSW Hall of Fame as “embarrassing,” arguing off-field conduct shouldn’t negate on-field excellence.

The “Legend” distinction, reserved for figures with transformative impacts on the game, includes icons like Jason Dunstall and Kevin Sheedy. Sheahan noted Carey’s influence: “He changed how the game was played. That’s undeniable.”

Controversy vs. Contribution
Critics argue the Hall of Fame’s criteria should reflect character. Carey’s 2007 U.S. arrest—where he pleaded guilty to assaulting officers—and multiple public incidents complicate his case. Former teammates and pundits remain divided, with some labeling him a “flawed genius.”

[IMAGE: Carey during a TV appearance, reflecting on his career regrets]
Caption: Carey has openly addressed his past mistakes in media interviews.

The Verdict
The debate mirrors wider conversations about separating art from artist in sports. As Sheahan quipped: “Wayne’s had his discretions. But who hasn’t?” The AFL faces pressure to clarify whether “Legend” status honors pure on-field achievement or demands broader integrity.

Carey’s fate rests with Hall of Fame committees, but his story underscores sport’s enduring struggle to balance talent and morality. For now, “The King” remains a paradox—a player whose brilliance and baggage are inextricably linked.

[IMAGE: Current AFL CEO Andrew Dillon, who informed Carey of his 2023 NSW Hall of Fame exclusion]
Caption: AFL leadership must weigh Carey’s legacy against league values.

Share or comment on this article: Top footy expert makes a VERY controversial call about AFL trouble magnet Wayne Carey