Will John McGlynn Stay Loyal to Falkirk’s Key Players After Historic Campaign?
Falkirk’s Premiership Reality Check: McGlynn’s Tough Decisions Loom
By Paul Forsyth | Updated: 18:53 BST, 10 August 2025
Falkirk’s fairytale return to the Scottish Premiership after 15 years is facing an early reality check. Despite a spirited 2-2 draw with Dundee United in their opener, a 3-1 loss at Livingston highlighted gaps in their squad. Manager John McGlynn, lauded for back-to-back promotions, now faces a pivotal question: can his League One-tested squad survive the top flight?
[Insert Image 1: John McGlynn on the touchline, looking pensive during Falkirk’s match against Livingston.]
Limited Reinforcements, Familiar Faces
McGlynn has largely stuck with the squad that secured promotion, adding only veteran striker Brian Graham, defender Lewis Neilson, and goalkeeper Scott Bain. While loyalty to players who delivered success is understandable, the step up to the Premiership demands higher quality. Livingston exposed Falkirk’s defensive frailty, with Neilson’s costly error leading to Scott Pittman’s opener. Lewis Smith then capitalized on slack marking to score a stunning second.
Ross MacIver’s header offered hope, but Jeremy Bokila’s late goal—exploiting a disorganized backline—sealed the win. These lapses have intensified calls for reinforcements.
[Insert Image 2: Jeremy Bokila celebrates after scoring Livingston’s third goal against Falkirk.]
Tactical Tweaks or Transfer Moves?
McGlynn, a seasoned coach with three decades of experience, isn’t blind to the challenge. While his attacking philosophy thrilled fans in lower leagues, the Premiership demands pragmatism. Southampton and Ipswich’s Premier League relegations serve as warnings: principles alone don’t guarantee survival.
Falkirk’s boss must decide whether to adapt tactics or overhaul personnel. Loans from English clubs are rumored, but time is short—the transfer window closes in three weeks.
[Insert Image 3: Brian Graham in action during Falkirk’s pre-season friendly.]
Defensive Woes and Fixture Gauntlet
The defense, a cornerstone of past success, now looks vulnerable. Livingston’s three goals stemmed from individual errors and tactical gaps. With Celtic, Hibernian, and Aberdeen next, improvements are urgent. Midfielder Coll Donaldson admitted: “We’ve got to learn quickly.”
Conclusion: A Defining Month
McGlynn’s faith in his squad is admirable, but sentimentality risks relegation. Recruitment must match ambition, and tactical flexibility could be key. As Falkirk prepares for Celtic Park, the next few weeks will shape their season—and McGlynn’s legacy.
Share or comment on this article: Can John McGlynn’s Falkirk survive their Premiership test?
Images: Getty/Daily Mail
Follow us for more Scottish football updates.
